Jessica Lowndes Rocks House, Jessica Alba Goes Cutesy On Halloween

They’re two of Hollywood’s most attractive celebrities. They share the same first name, and they were both at Heidi Klum’s annual Halloween party.

But their sense of costume style could not have been more different. Jessica Lowndes’ costume revealed why Halloween parties (and their resulting photos) are such a treat for male celebrity fans. Jessica Alba, meanwhile, went a bit more family-friendly–offering a take on Dora the Explorer that, while more mature than the Nickelodeon cartoon character, certainly did not scream “trashy Halloween party.”

Whose costume was better?